The difference is mostly where you choose the ring and when you see the price. Everything below about Payne Anthony comes from its own website, read on the afternoon of October 29, 2026, and Beylora prices come from our catalog read the same afternoon. Hours and terms change, so check with the store before you go.
What Payne Anthony Jewelers lists
- Where it is: 329 Trolley Square in Salt Lake City. Its location page (opens in a new tab) lists Tuesday through Saturday from 11am to 7pm, closed Sunday and Monday, as its home page also says; a banner on the location page says Monday through Saturday, so call ahead on a Monday.
- History: its history page (opens in a new tab) says the store began in Trolley Square as Charles Anthony Jewelers in 1972 and took the Payne Anthony name in the late 1970s, and its home page says it is now part of the Jonathan's Jewelry family of Cottonwood Heights; see Jonathan's Jewelry in Salt Lake City and Beylora.
- How a custom ring works there: its custom engagement ring page (opens in a new tab) starts with an online 3D ring designer, then an appointment to pick your center stone in the store and finish the design, with the ring ready in a couple of weeks. Its design process page (opens in a new tab) adds an estimate, a deposit, a CAD drawing and a wax model, and two quality inspections before delivery.
- Lab-grown diamonds and prices: the pages we could read did not mention lab-grown diamonds, name a grading lab or show ring prices, and its diamond search pages asked for a browser check, so we could not read them. Ask the store if a lab-grown center matters to you.
How buying works at each
| Step | Payne Anthony Jewelers and Beylora |
|---|---|
| Choosing the ring | Payne Anthony: design online in 3D, then choose the center stone at the store. Beylora: choose a complete ring online, or try settings at our studio in Provo by appointment |
| Seeing the price | Payne Anthony: an estimate during the design process. Beylora: every ring's complete price is on its page |
| The center diamond | Payne Anthony: not stated on the pages we read. Beylora: lab-grown, at least 1ct, D color and VVS1 or VVS2 clarity, with its own IGI report |
| How long it takes | Payne Anthony: a couple of weeks, per its custom page. Beylora: about 30 days, delivered free, insured and signed for |
| Changing your mind | Payne Anthony: we found no return terms on the pages we read; its process takes a deposit, so ask how it is handled. Beylora: cancel within 48 hours of ordering and get every dollar back, or return the ring within 30 days of delivery with a 20% restocking fee |
| After you buy | Payne Anthony: two quality inspections before delivery; we found no warranty terms. Beylora: the Beylora Lifetime Guarantee covers one repair or replacement for the life of your ring, center diamond included |
Queenstown
Bellagio
Big Sur
Como
Payne Anthony is the better fit if you want to pick your center stone in person and finish the design in its Trolley Square store. Under the guarantee the repair or replacement is free, you pay the shipping to us and the shipping back to you, and a lost or stolen ring is not covered.
What a complete Beylora ring costs
The Payne Anthony pages we could read show no ring prices, so here is what a finished Beylora ring costs, so you have a number to hold next to any estimate.
- 1ct lab-grown center: from $1,000 in 14k gold, in 46 classic plain solitaires such as Queenstown
- 1.5ct lab-grown center: from $1,250
- 2ct lab-grown center: from $1,500
- 3ct lab-grown center: from $2,000, with sizes up to 5ct
Each price includes the setting and the lab-grown center diamond, graded D color and VVS1 or VVS2 clarity on its own IGI report, before tax. 18k gold adds $500 and platinum adds $700. Every ring is made to order and arrives in about 30 days, free, insured and signed for.
When you visit any store, ask for the complete price in writing, whether the center is natural or lab-grown, its weight, color and clarity, and which lab graded it.
For other Salt Lake City stores, see 9th & 9th Jewelers in Salt Lake City and Beylora, Philip & Co in Salt Lake City and Beylora, Tresor Jewelers in Salt Lake City and Beylora and Timeless Design and Jewelry in Salt Lake City and Beylora, or the county overview, engagement rings in Salt Lake County.
If anything about Payne Anthony Jewelers has changed, email marketing@beylora.com and we will correct it.
Questions about Payne Anthony Jewelers and Beylora
Where is Payne Anthony Jewelers and is it open on Saturday?
Payne Anthony Jewelers is at 329 Trolley Square in Salt Lake City. Its location page, read October 29, 2026, lists Saturday from 11am to 7pm and Sunday closed. Beylora sells complete lab-grown rings online, ships free to Salt Lake City, and has a studio in Provo by appointment.
Does Payne Anthony Jewelers sell lab-grown diamonds?
The Payne Anthony pages we could read did not mention lab-grown diamonds, so ask the store before you visit. Every Beylora engagement ring has a lab-grown center diamond of at least 1ct, graded D color and VVS1 or VVS2 clarity on its own IGI report.
How does a custom engagement ring work at Payne Anthony?
Payne Anthony's site says you start in its online 3D ring designer, then book an appointment to choose a center stone in the store and finish the design, with an estimate, a deposit, a CAD drawing and a wax model along the way. It says the ring can be ready in a couple of weeks.
How much is a Beylora engagement ring compared with a Salt Lake City store?
The Payne Anthony pages we could read showed no ring prices, and its diamond search pages asked for a browser check, so we cannot compare the same ring. A complete Beylora ring starts at $1,000 with a 1ct lab-grown center, $1,500 with a 2ct and $2,000 with a 3ct in 14k gold, before tax, with free insured delivery.