Choosing a jeweler is a lot of tabs and a lot of opinions, usually while you are keeping a secret. So instead of a ranking, here is each store in a sentence, taken from its own website, with a link to the full side by side on our site. We sell online and see couples at our studio in Provo by appointment, and the visit is free. We do not have a store in Salt Lake County.
Queenstown
Bellagio
Big Sur
Como
What a 2ct lab-grown ring cost at seven county jewelers
These are the 2ct lab-grown rings, or diamond plus setting, we could price on each store's own website on October 29 and 30, 2026, next to the matching Beylora ring in 14k gold. Each comparison page names the exact ring, its grades and its shape.
- Morgan Jewelers: $2,421.99 for a 2ct D VVS2 lab-grown oval and a 14K oval solitaire setting sold separately, before any charge to set the diamond or size the ring. Beylora: $1,500.
- McKay Diamonds: $2,920 for a 2.08ct E VS1 lab-grown emerald cut solitaire. Beylora: $1,500 with a 2ct center.
- Classic Jewelers Exchange: $3,221.16 for a 2ct lab-grown round solitaire, F to G color and VS clarity. Beylora: $1,500.
- Shane Co.: $3,650 for a lab-grown round bezel ring listed at 2ct total weight with 12 small accents, G to H color and VS2 clarity. Beylora: $1,700 for Valencia, an oval bezel ring with a 2ct center.
- J. Brooks Jewelers: $3,840 for a hidden halo with a 2.01ct D VS1 lab-grown oval. Beylora: $1,700.
- Jonathan's Jewelry: $4,296 for a 2ct lab-created round solitaire with no color or clarity listed. Beylora: $1,500.
- June Rings: $4,400 for a cushion ring with a 2.00ct F VS1 lab diamond. Beylora: $1,500.
Prices change on both sides, so check each listing before you decide. A store you can walk into, repairs down the street or a designer who sketches with you are worth something too, and the list below says which store offers what.
Salt Lake City
- O.C. Tanner Jewelers, downtown Salt Lake City: the jeweler that calls itself Utah's original jeweler, founded in 1927, for a natural diamond chosen in person. O.C. Tanner Jewelers and Beylora compared.
- Bennion Jewelers, downtown Salt Lake City: run by the Bennion family since 1952 and a member of the American Gem Society, where you choose and price a ring in person. Bennion Jewelers and Beylora compared.
- AAA Jewelers, downtown Salt Lake City: a family jeweler founded in 1946 for a natural GIA diamond, quoted on request. AAA Jewelers and Beylora compared.
- Payne Anthony Jewelers, Trolley Square: design a ring online, then pick the center stone in person at a store that began there in 1972. Payne Anthony Jewelers and Beylora compared.
- 9th & 9th Jewelers, Salt Lake City: designs a lab-grown ring from scratch by appointment, with a price quoted once you share your idea. 9th & 9th Jewelers and Beylora compared.
- Philip & Co, 2100 South, Salt Lake City: a family jeweler that started as a wholesale firm in 1958, for shopping in person. Philip & Co and Beylora compared.
- Timeless Design and Jewelry, 900 South, Salt Lake City: browse engagement rings in the shop or design one with its jewelers, priced by the shop. Timeless Design and Jewelry and Beylora compared.
- Tresor Jewelers, Salt Lake City: two stores and a free sketch for a custom ring, with certified lab-grown loose diamonds from $750 and the setting priced separately. Tresor Jewelers and Beylora compared.
- Rocky Mountain Diamond Company, Commerce Drive, Salt Lake City: a diamond with a GIA report and a setting chosen separately, from one showroom. Rocky Mountain Diamond Company and Beylora compared.
- McKay Diamonds, Salt Lake City: lab-grown rings ready to ship in days and custom work made in house. McKay Diamonds and Beylora compared.
- Jonathan's Jewelry, Highland Drive, Salt Lake City: design a ring online and pick the center stone in the store. Jonathan's Jewelry and Beylora compared.
- Steadman's Fine Jewelry, Salt Lake Valley: a family jeweler in business since 1904 that makes a custom ring with you in person and quotes it by phone or in person. Steadman's Fine Jewelry and Beylora compared.
Midvale, Murray and the middle of the valley
- Shane Co., State Street, Midvale: its one Utah store, open seven days a week, with free repairs and resizing. Shane Co. and Beylora compared.
- Classic Jewelers Exchange, Midvale: a family-owned counter to walk into, ordering from a large supplier catalog, with sizing and repairs in the same store. Classic Jewelers Exchange and Beylora compared.
- Ari Diamonds, Midvale: a family jeweler that sources a natural or lab-grown diamond for you and quotes the ring. Ari Diamonds and Beylora compared.
- Limb Jewelers, Midvale: a family jeweler in business since 1949 that designs and makes a custom ring in its own shop over about three to four weeks. Limb Jewelers and Beylora compared.
- J. Brooks Jewelers, Murray: a family owned store, also in Lehi, with its own designs. J. Brooks Jewelers and Beylora compared.
- KAY Jewelers, Murray and West Jordan: two stores where you can try rings on the same day. KAY Jewelers and Beylora compared.
- Morgan Jewelers, Salt Lake City, Sandy, West Valley City and Murray: four stores across the county. Morgan Jewelers and Beylora compared.
Draper, South Jordan and West Jordan
- June Rings, Draper: an independently owned studio making rings to order, visited by appointment. June Rings and Beylora compared.
- Jewelry By You, South Jordan: a goldsmith-led store with free first sizing and cleanings. Jewelry By You and Beylora compared.
- Salt Lake City Diamonds, West Jordan: a family-owned shop that designs a custom ring with you and keeps repairs in the building. Salt Lake City Diamonds and Beylora compared.
More for Salt Lake County couples
Read the county overview, engagement rings in Salt Lake County, or the guides for Sandy, Draper and South Jordan, Murray, Midvale and Holladay and West Jordan, West Valley City and Taylorsville. On a budget, start with engagement rings under $2,000 in Salt Lake County.
If anything about a store here has changed, email marketing@beylora.com and we will correct it.
Salt Lake City jewelry store questions
What are the best jewelry stores in Salt Lake City, Utah?
It depends on what you want, so we do not rank them. O.C. Tanner, Bennion and AAA Jewelers are long-standing downtown jewelers, 9th & 9th and Steadman's design custom rings with you, and Shane Co., KAY and Morgan have stores you can walk into across the valley. Beylora sells complete lab-grown rings online with every price posted on the ring's own page, delivered free in Salt Lake County.
Who sells engagement rings in Salt Lake City?
The 22 Salt Lake County jewelers on this page all sell or make engagement rings, from downtown stores such as O.C. Tanner and Bennion to Shane Co. in Midvale and June Rings in Draper. Beylora also sells to Salt Lake City couples online: complete lab-grown rings from $1,000 at 1ct, $1,500 at 2ct in 14k gold, with free insured delivery in about 30 days.
Where can I buy a lab-grown engagement ring in Salt Lake City?
Several Salt Lake County jewelers on this page list lab-grown diamonds, including McKay Diamonds, Tresor, 9th & 9th, Morgan, Shane Co. and KAY. Beylora sells only lab-grown engagement rings, each center diamond D color and VVS1 or VVS2 clarity with its own IGI report, in centers from 1ct up to 5ct.
How much is a 2ct lab-grown engagement ring at Salt Lake City jewelers?
At seven Salt Lake County jewelers we read on October 29 and 30, 2026, a 2ct lab-grown ring, or diamond plus setting, ran from $2,421.99 at Morgan to $4,400 at June Rings, with the shapes and grades named on this page. The matching Beylora rings were $1,500 to $1,700 in 14k gold.
Does Beylora have a store in Salt Lake City?
No. Beylora sells online, delivers free and insured anywhere in Salt Lake County in about 30 days, and meets couples at its studio in Provo by appointment. If you want to walk into a store the same day, Shane Co., KAY and Morgan have stores across the valley, while 9th & 9th Jewelers and June Rings see couples by appointment.